First the "190 Quota" is facetious and based on testimony of a Director at Mary Bridge trying to discredit a good and ethical doctor, providing a second opinion, the only one willing to help right a wrong.

Dr. Lamb was attempting to discredit another Doctor, who had provided an opinion that contradicted Dr. Lamb's opinion.
She testified that a pediatrician seeing approximately 5,000 patients per year should make
“at least” 190 CPS referrals and suggested that substantial deviation below that number would cause her to question what was occurring in that physician’s patient population.

This was not casual conversation. It was expert testimony offered in rebuttal by Mary Bridge's expert in court testimony, to discredit another physician’s credibility. This was a preplanned question that did not come out of the blue. It does not seem likely the Assistant Attorney General came up with the question out of the blue. 

Where Did “190” Come From?

Was it Innocent Errors, or Purposeful Falsification? 
Is it reasonable that the 190 figure did not cause this "expert" to think twice about what she was saying?

You decide.

The calculation deserves careful examination. 
To come up with it, Dr. Lamb need to make one serious mistake, and two incorrect assumptions - 
three material errors that are not in line with the expertise listed in the body of knowledge for Child Abuse Pediatricians. (Note 1)

In addition to the expectations of knowledge laid out in the body of knowledge for Child Abuse Pediatrician, (See Note Dr. Lamb's testimony appears to contain several fundamental statistical problems:

Dr. Lamb's "Innocent Mistake #1". Using 38 per 1000 instead of the correct number, 25.3.
A percentage appears to have been erroneously used instead of the much lower actual rate per 1000. What is the correct screened-in count per 1000? (See Below for the NCANDS Data) 

The only way to get 190 for 5000, is to incorrectly use a 38 rate for 1000 then multiply it by 5. 
Dr. Lamb must have used the "percentage screened in", not the rate. 
The only "38" listed in NCANDS data for Washington State, according to the source material reviewed, is a percentage of screened-in reports, not a count per 1000—not a finding that pediatricians should make 38 CPS referrals for every 1,000 patients they see.
The correct rate (not percentage) screen-in per 1000 is use 66.6 per 1000 and multiply by the correct screening in rate of 38% to get the correct amount screened in per 1000 children: 66.6 x 38% = 25.3

Dr. Lamb's "Innocent Mistake #2".  All Calls to CPS do not originate from Family Pediatricians. In fact, only 8- 10% of Referrals come from all Medical Providers, not 100%.  Pediatricians are only a fraction of that 8-10%. 
Dr. Lamb certainly is aware of this as an "expert" that people other than Pediatricians call CPS. In addition to all the other mandated reporters (educators, law enforcement, etc. ) calls come in from family members, neighbors, people who observe concerns in public, etc. 

Dr. Lamb's "Innocent Mistake #3" - "Seeing 5000 Patients" does not mean 5000 different Children. Patient visits were treated as though they represented unique children.A pediatrician who has 5,000 patient encounters is seeing some of those children for repeat visits in one year. Children routinely see their pediatrician more than once.

These distinctions matter enormously when someone multiplies a statistic by 5,000 and arrives at a purported expectation of 190 child-abuse referrals per year.

Why This Testimony Matters

Dr. Lamb was not merely discussing child-abuse reporting statistics. She was using her calculation PURPOSEFULLY to DISCREDIT another pediatrician whose professional opinion differed from hers.

Questions Pediatricians Should Be Asking - Do I trust Mary Bridge's CAID Office, and how can I document more thoroughly so my patients do not lose their loving and safe parents? How can I help hold Mary Bridge accountable?
Why does the Washington State Medical Association refuse to investigate Dr. Lamb?

 

Below is Dr. Lamb's testimony. Read it and the underlying source for yourself.

 

In rebuttal, after a Family Paid for Expert testified that she reported that she reports 2-5 per year, and had just reported one the prior weekend, that her numbers had been higher in prior years. Based on actual NCANDS data (not Dr. Lamb fabricated data to falsely discredited a good doctor, this is a typical number. 

What IS a reasonable number?

It's not that hard to be precise and reasonable, in a courtroom, where your "expert" opinion carries so much weight that Judge's rely on your word to determine if a child is removed from their family. Be Ethical. 

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 

First, determine what percentage of all referrals come from Pediatricians in private practice. 
According to NCANDS, all medical providers represent 8-10% of all child abuse and neglect referrals, not 100% as Doctor Lamb assumed.

According to the Child Maltreatment 2022 report, published by the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services on January 29, 2024, most child abuse referrals come from professionals such as educators, law enforcement, and social services. Pediatricians and other medical professionals typically account for around 8-10% of all child abuse referrals. In contrast, educators report the highest percentage (over 20%), followed by legal and law enforcement personnel. However, pediatricians' reports often carry significant weight due to their medical expertise in identifying physical and behavioral signs of abuse. Therefore I will use 9% of referrals.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 

Second, find a reasonable number of unique patients if a doctor is seeing 5000 patients per year, some of them are repeats from the same patients. How many actual patients would there be? A reasonable answer would be based on some data. 

AAP Bright Futures Guidelines – Recommends well-child visit schedules from infancy through adolescence.
Infants (0-1 year old): Around 6-7 visits in the 1st year (newborn visits, & well-child checkups at 1, 2, 4, 6, 9, &12 mos).

Toddlers (1-3 years old): About 2-3 visits per year for well-child checkups.

Preschool and School-Age (4-10 years old): Typically 1 visit per year for an annual well-child, plus occasional sick visits.

Adolescents (11-18 years old): Usually 1 visit per year, though some may have additional visits for sports physicals, vaccinations, or health concerns.
MEPS (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality - AHRQ) – Provides national data on healthcare visits, showing an average of 1.5 to 2 visits per year per child in pediatric settings.
Therefore 1.75 seem like a reasonable number for the average number of visits, though we should note hhat younger children have a higher frequency of referrals.

5000 appointments / 1.75 = roughly unique patients seen per year. 

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 

Third, use the correct rate of 66.6 per 1000 and multiply by the correct screening in rate of 38% to get the correct amount screened in per 1000 children: 66.6 x 38% = 25.3 per 1000, not 38. 

According to the Child Maltreatment 2022 report, published by the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services on January 29, 2024, most child abuse referrals come from professionals such as educators, law enforcement, and social services. Pediatricians and other medical professionals typically account for around 8-10% of all child abuse referrals. In contrast, educators report the highest percentage (over 20%), followed by legal and law enforcement personnel. However, pediatricians' reports often carry significant weight due to their medical expertise in identifying physical and behavioral signs of abuse. Therefore 9% of referrals is a reasonable percentage. 

So 2857 children would generate approximately 
(2.857 thousand x 25.3 per 1000 = 72.3 referrals x 9% for the estimated number for all  Medical Professional: about 6.5, not 190. 
and that is for all medical providers not just pediatricians. Many come from hospital ER including nurses, dentists and other medical professionals. 
Assume half come from Pediatricians in Private Practice and you are now at 3-4 per year for a Pediatrician seeing 5000 patients per year.

3 to 4 per year, not 190, is a more accurate estimate of the average* number of referrals from a Family Pediatrician. 

How could Dr. Lamb sit in a courtroom and testify to such blatant falsification?
How many times has she done this?
How many children have lost their good and safe parents due to testimony like this?

Note 1: Understanding NCANDS statistics was expressly part of the American Board of Pediatrics' "Body of Knowledge" for Child Abuse Pediatrics. The Board specifically expected CAPs to know the NCANDS data system and the sources of its information, and to understand the strengths and weaknesses of administrative and clinical data used to determine child-abuse incidence and prevalence. 
This is a Standard of Care Issue.


What was going on with Dr. Lamb's testimony and why would she get it so wrong?

YOU DECIDE.

Mary Bridge Leadership has no issue with anything Dr. Lamb has said or done to children or families. They have not admitted to any wrongdoing on her part.